Prototyping and Early Production
Prototyping is a crucial and dynamic phase in the product design process. For the work I do with clients, I define it as the creation of a reasonable to high quality product quickly and without requiring substantial capital investment. This typically involves low-volume production methods such as machining and additive manufacturing, as opposed to capital-intensive techniques like casting or injection molding. The aim is to produce a prototype that is not only functional but sometimes intentionally higher quality to extend its testing lifespan.
The key to effective prototyping lies in prioritizing the right features for the product’s stage of development. In the early phases, when your focus is on customer discovery to validate core features are desired, the goal is to be agile—iterating quickly based on test results. To do this, it’s essential to build units that are functional and presentable enough to be considered a reasonably finished product in the eyes of the consumer. Ideally, they should be refined enough that you can sell them, and begin gathering input from actual users as soon as possible, driving improvements while generating revenue and without risky upfront production costs.
This philosophy extends into how I prefer to approach internal, or working prototypes. If your product isn’t ready for customer-facing interaction but is necessary for internal development—whether it's to test electronics, software integration, or ergonomic aspects—the unit should allow for internal modifications. In these cases, a modular design is optimal, enabling quick adjustments as you refine other components of your system. For items regularly disassembled and reassembled, this is where the reliability is beefed up to bear excessive handling not expected in a finished product.
Once the design is ready for customer deployment, surface texture appearance and feel become more critical. Today’s 3D printing technology has significantly evolved, offering excellent surface finishes, strength, accuracy, and durability at accessible price points. I have a high-quality 3D printer in-house for same-day and next-day testing, but I’ve found that I often outsource printed parts instead because it’s so cost efficient for such high quality. The versatility of 3D printing allows for the production of refined, market-ready parts at a fraction of the cost associated with traditional manufacturing methods.
Given the commoditization of these high-quality, low-volume production methods, the financial crossover point for investing in capital tooling (e.g., mold tooling) typically occurs after you surpass 1,000 units. This rule of thumb provides a baseline for calculating the cost-effectiveness of your parts. If you can profitably sell your product with 3D-printed or machined components, then you have a viable path to market. In this scenario, the goal is to sell as many units as possible while continuing to gather valuable customer feedback, before transitioning to more scalable and cost-efficient manufacturing methods as demand grows.
In short, prototyping isn’t just about testing a product’s core functionality—it’s about balancing rapid iteration, quality, and market readiness, all while keeping costs manageable. By focusing on these principles, you can streamline the transition from prototype to production while maintaining flexibility and maximizing customer insights.
Stop struggling and start selling
It’s ok if you’re just curious about your options. Let's start with a conversation, I'll give you an idea of expectations and provide you with a quote.